3 reasons not to buy a lightweight hose (yet!)

130720-1337

You’ve probably seen the ads, even if you haven’t bought one. For about twenty bucks you get a wrinkly coil of compressed flexible hose with plastic fittings on the ends.

It’s supposed to be a wonderful new invention. Imagine, a hose that weighs less than the water inside it! Look how easy it is to handle! I had to try it.

130720-1338

reason #1 not to buy one

130720-1339The one I bought is blue and 25 feet long when it is fully engorged with high-pressure water. Following the instructions I screwed it into the faucet, closed the plastic valve on the far end, and slowly turned on the water. Within a few seconds the wrinkled hose began to expand, turning into a semi-rigid cylinder and lengthening from about six feet out to the full 25 foot extent.

Cool! I screwed my trusty hand sprayer onto the end and carefully opened the valve. Then I squeezed the sprayer, to let some water out.

I expected that water would spray out with full force, since the hose appeared to be fully expanded. I got that full spray for less than a second, before the end of the hose nearest to the sprayer literally collapsed, issuing a strange moaning sound. Instantly, the flow coming out the sprayer dropped to a trickle. Huh? A little voice in my head said “Venturi effect!”

I stopped the spray and allowed the hose to re-expand. Tried again… same result.

Let’s see… maybe there needs to be more pressure? I opened up the faucet valve further, and tried again. Nope. Even more pressure! Again… nope. Still, the far end of the hose collapsed, diminishing the flow to a mere trickle.

I was not able to get a decent spray from this hose until after opening the faucet to at least two full turns of the handle. After that, it seemed to work okay. There does not seem to be any way to operate this hose with less than full pressure. That is a problem for me because I prefer to use a nice, gentle, very slow flow to water the container garden’s many new seedlings.

That in itself is enough reason for me to not buy another one. But wait… there’s more.

reason #2

One of my garden clients bought one of the longer green ones. At first it seemed like an improvement. Now we can reach distant corners of the garden without dragging a heavy, damaging object across delicate plants. The new hose can rest on top of bushes and other sturdy plants, lightly, without damaging them. Excellent!

130720-1340So my client started using it in the back garden. Then, one day, after finishing the watering, my client shut off the sprayer head, preparing to turn off the water at the faucet. Seconds later, there was a “pop” and water began spraying out of a point in the middle of the hose. Uh oh!

On examination of the rupture point it could be seen that the hose is made of an outer mesh-like layer and an inner band of plastic that spirals around the hose. That plastic band had broken, and the outer mesh layer was insufficient to hold in the water.

Why did this happen? My best guess is that the hose was left in the sun (a big no-no according to the instructions) and suffered UV damage. But this hose was less than a month old. If these hoses are so vulnerable to sun damage that they bust after just a few weeks sitting in the sun, I feel reluctant to even use them in the sun. Since most gardens receive direct sunlight, this is a problem.

reason #3

Handling hoses is always a bit of a challenge. I was hoping that the new, lightweight hose would be easier to handle, and it is in a way. It is certainly a lot lighter. But in my gardens there are places that should never have a hose running over them, places where the plants are just too delicate.

With the old-style, heavy rubber and plastic hoses, it is possible to thread the hose around sturdy hose-guides stretegically placed at important garden corners. Then if I need more hose length, I can pull from a distance, and the hose snakes around the guide, neatly staying on the path or sidewalk.

With the new hoses, not so much. The darn things are so light and rigid that they don’t stay under the hose guides. Instead, they curve up in big arcs, flopping all over the plants. Not so good!

waiting for a redesign?

These three problems are enough to keep me from buying or recommending the lightweight hoses, at least for now. But this is only the first draft of these new-design hoses. I am sure that many people are experiencing these and maybe other problems with the new hoses. No doubt the makers are receiving complaints and requests for refunds.

I will be watching for a revised version, maybe made out of slightly less UV-sensitive plastic and fabric, and maybe with just a tiny bit more heft. Maybe the low-flow problem can also be solved (but due to the laws of physics, it is arguable that no collapsible hose of this type will ever be able to run at low pressure).

If I see a redesigned lightweight hose, I’ll get one and report back in these pages. Until then, I suggest you avoid them.

what do you think of them?

Have you bought one and tried it? Please reply in the comments and let us know what you think of it.

Advertisements
2 comments
  1. I brought a 33m “my garden path” Expanding Hose via TV Shopping Solutions. The hose firstly came apart from the spray nozzle, I managed to get it back together but to my utter disappointment the inner rubber hose then split about 2m from the end. I have tried in vain to contact the supplier to no avail. My advice Do NOT purchase this hose, it is an utter waste of good money.

  2. Joanne Lloyd said:

    We have purchased two expanding hoses this summer! The first a 20′ hose purchased on-line (don’t remember the brand name) split in the center of the hose as in problem #2. The second hose, again a 20′ expandable (don’t recall the brand name) purchased at a local nursery burst at the spray nozzle. Did I mention these were purchased within one month of each other!!!! I do hope there can be a significant improvement in the design of these since they are easier to handle and take up much less room to store.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s